So you love food? Like me! and as my son asked this very good question, how does someone become a food critic? i thought id look into it! and same goes with you, as you might find my advice useful. You love restaurants, you love trying new flavours, you love sitting at the table after the lights dim and wondering whether the dish in front of you is really worth the hype. Perhaps you’ve even thought: Could I be the one writing about it? Enter the world of the food critic.
Becoming a food critic doesn’t mean you’ll start off reviewing Michelin-starred tasting menus at five-figure restaurants (though you might someday). It means developing a sharp palate, a clear voice, and a network of opportunities. Below is a friendly (and practical) roadmap—with some inspiration from one prominent UK critic, Grace Dent, to show how someone actually did it.
1. Build your food literacy
Before you review other people’s food, you’ll want to know a few things:
• Eat widely. Try everything from street food to fine dining, familiar flavours to foreign ones. The more varied your experiences, the better your comparisons and context.
• Learn the language. Can you describe texture (crispy, velvety, chewy), flavour balance (sweet/savoury/acid/tannin), presentation (rustic vs. slick) and service ambience? The best critics find words that paint a meal, not just list it.
• Understand the industry basics. What is a Michelin star? What is a tasting menu vs à la carte? How do kitchens run? That helps you judge with context and insight—not just “was it nice?”
2. Practice writing (and publishing)
You may be a better diner than a writer and that’s fine. But to be a critic you need to express your opinions well. Here’s how:
• Start a blog or social account (Instagram, Medium, whatever suits your style). Write short reviews of restaurants you visit, even small ones. Show evidence of your taste, your style, your voice.
• Focus on voice. Are you witty? Thoughtful? Analytical? Skeptical? The critics I admire have a distinctive voice.
• Get feedback. Ask friends or online followers what they respond to. What sentences stand out? What doesn’t work?
3. Get into journalism or food media
This is where Grace Dent’s story offers a helpful blueprint.
• Grace studied English Literature at the University of Stirling.
• While at university and soon after, she wrote for magazines (e.g., features for Cosmopolitan) and worked as an editorial assistant at Marie Claire.
• She freelanced for magazines like Glamour and worked for newspapers/online publications. Over time she specialised in media, culture and eventually food.
• Eventually she became the restaurant critic at The Guardian from January 2018.
What you can learn: She didn’t start just writing restaurant reviews—she started broader in writing and media, built her portfolio, and then honed into food criticism.
Practical tip: Try to get writing or editing gigs (even small ones) in magazines, newspapers, websites. These help you build credibility. Then pitch food-oriented pieces (restaurant reviews, chef interviews, food trends). With enough experience, you may get noticed by larger outlets or be invited to review bigger restaurants.
4. Create your niche and voice
Food criticism isn’t just about saying “that was lovely” or “that was terrible”. It’s about offering insight: what makes the place tick, how the chef shows up in the dish, whether the menu fulfils its promise. To stand out:
• Decide what your angle is. Maybe you’re passionate about vegetarian food, or behind the scenes of food supply, or global street food.
• Use your voice consistently. Write with personality. Grace Dent, for example, is known for being witty, sharp-tongued, yet accessible. She once said of herself: “It is an absolute fluke that I am in doing what I do… The only reason I am doing it is because it is one of the only things I can do.”
• Keep your standards high. The audiences for food criticism expect more than “nice steak, good wine”. They expect insight. Ask: why did this dish succeed? What’s missing? Is the restaurant over-hyped?
5. Network, visit restaurants responsibly, and understand ethics
• Visit restaurants regularly. The more you eat, the more you learn. But learn to rotate visits and restaurants so you don’t burn out or become jaded.
• Build relationships. Get to know chefs, PRs, restaurant managers—but maintain independence. Your credibility relies on impartiality.
• Understand ethics. Many critics pay for their own meals (or are clear when they are comped), disclose conflicts, avoid letting free meals influence their reviews.
• Attend press launches, sample menus, restaurant openings—but also go anonymously sometimes, to get the ‘normal customer’ experience.
6. Get published (and then expand your reach)
• Pitch to local publications, food blogs, smaller websites. Even short restaurant reviews count.
• Offer a unique angle: “10 under-£20 lunches in London”, “Hidden vegetarian spots in Manchester”, etc.
• Once you’ve built a body of work, approach larger outlets. Show your best pieces, highlight your voice, your niche, your writing skills.
• Expand into podcasting, radio, hosting events. Grace Dent runs her own food-podcast “Comfort Eating”.
• Social media helps: share your reviews, photos, foodie adventures. It builds an audience and visibility.
7. Keep evolving and learning
• The food world changes fast: new cuisines, sustainability issues, dietary trends, restaurant business shifts. Stay curious.
• Critique beyond food: service, ambience, value, concept, sustainability.
• Be humble. Even top critics learn from every meal. As Grace Dent recounts from her working-class childhood in Carlisle and evolving palate.
• Stay authentic. Your readers trust you because you are you. Don’t fake a persona.
Bonus: A quick checklist to get started this week
• Pick a local restaurant you’ve not visited. Try a full meal. Take notes: atmosphere, service, dish by dish, price vs value.
• Write a 300-word review in your voice. What stood out? What didn’t? Would you go back?
• Post it on your blog or social media. Ask a friend for feedback.
• Make a list of 5 publications or blogs you could pitch to (local paper, food blog, online magazine).
• Subscribe to a food-journalism or restaurant-business newsletter to keep up with trends.
Summary
Becoming a food critic is a journey of eating, writing, learning, networking and specialising. You start modestly: write reviews, build a portfolio, hone your voice. Use journalism or content-creation gigs to gain experience. As shown by Grace Dent’s path—from student writer to freelance journalist to leading restaurant critic at The Guardian—you don’t need a direct “food critic” job at the outset; you build into it. Stay curious, honest, spirited—and keep tasting!
Check out our Goodordering foodie t-shirts. Did you know that the brand name Goodordering came from when you feel like you have ordered well when you go out to eat. Have you dodged the food envy bug? and chosen well or has someone ordered well for the whole table?
If you know someone who loves Ramen, chips, lasagna or even cheese you need to check out these foodie varsity t-shirts from Goodordering.
